I asked Jeff the "The Berkey Guy" about the Berkey filters and the water probelms in Toledo, Ohio, related to cyanobacteria.
It seems that the Black Berkey purification elements would work well.
 Below is the full reply:
ALGAE BLOOM – FAQ
    Below is some information that might be helpful, with respect to the
    recent Algae
    Bloom and resulting contamination of the water supply to Toledo,
    Ohio:
    “…Cyanobacterial cells range in size from 0.5-1 μm to 40 μm in
    diameter…”
    In other words, it's a long skinny bacteria.
    Reference:
    http://huey.colorado.edu/cyanobacteria/about/cyanobacteria.php
    Internet research seems to indicate that cyanobacteria are even
    larger, typically
    on the scale of 150 micrometers in size.
    While we have not tested the specific microbes associated with Algae
    Blooms, we
    have tested other pathogenic bacteria and two viruses, which are a
    small fraction
    of the size of these microbes.
    To understand the difference between the size of pathogenic bacteria
    and
    viruses, we suggest the following web link as it will give you a
    great visual of the
    difference.
    The University of Utah Cell Size and Scale Chart:
    http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/cells/scale/
    Slide the scale at the bottom to see the size of virus vs bacteria
    vs other potential
    contaminates and magnify to greater levels.
    Black Berkey™ purification elements have been tested to remove both
    pathogenic bacteria and viruses to greater than the EPA purification
    standards.
    This suggests that larger bacteria, such as cyanobacteria, should
    also be
    effectively removed. Without test data on that specific microbe
    however, NMCL
    does not make that specific claim.
    The MS-2 virus is 24-26 nm in size.
    The Fr Coliphage virus is 25nm in size.
    In other words, they are over 1,000 times smaller than Cyanobateria.
    Additionally Microcystins, which are the chemical contaminates
    resulting from
    cyanobacteria are an organic chemical. Testing of Black Berkey™
    elements has
    demonstrated they are extremely efficient at removing organic
    chemicals.
    The EPA defines Microcystins as: “…toxins produced by cyanobacteria.
    Cyanobacteria are also known as blue-green algae and are ubiquitous
    in surface water
    when conditions are favorable for growth and formation of algal
    blooms. Cyanobacteria
    release toxins upon cell death or lysis. When released, toxins may
    persist for weeks to
    months. Toxins of most concern are microcystins. Microcystins take
    their name from the
    genera Microcystis. Most microcystins are hepatotoxins (liver
    toxins). Hepatotoxins are
    produced by species of the genera Microcystis, Anabena, Nodularia,
    Oscillatoria among
    others. Most microcystins are associated with Microcystis
    aeruginosa. While the liver is
    the primary target of microcystins, it is also a skin, eye and
    throat irritant…”
    Reference:
    http://iaspub.epa.gov/tdb/pages/contaminant/contaminantOverview.do
    Further, the EPA states that: “…The following processes are
    considered effective for
    the removal/oxidation of microcystin:…. powdered activated carbon
    (up to 100% for
    some microcystins but less so for others), granular activated carbon
    (time-dependent
    from 100% near start up to 38 to 73% at 3.5 months…”
    Reference:
    http://iaspub.epa.gov/tdb/pages/contaminant/treatmentSummary.do
    Finally, the EPA states that: “…Removal of total microcystins, M-LR,
    and M-LA, in
    water by granular activated carbon (GAC) can be very effective where
    the effectiveness
    is based on the empty bed contact time, the carbon's age, and
    possible biodegradation
    of the toxin. Time-dependent monitoring in a full-scale plant ranged
    43 to 60 percent
    removal for M-LR. Time-dependent monitoring in pilot-scale studies
    ranged from greater
    than 99 percent at one month to 73 percent at 3.5 months for M-LR,
    and from greater
    than 99 percent at one month to 38 percent at 3.5 months for M-LA…”
    REFERENCE:
http://iaspub.epa.gov/tdb/pages/contaminantProcess/contaminantProcessOvervie
    w.do
    Based upon the above Internet research, Black Berkey™ element
    microbe and
    organic chemical removal test data and the information provided by
    the EPA in
    their reference material cited above; these all suggest that Berkey®
    water
    purification systems should be extremely effective at removing and
    reducing
    contaminates resulting from the current algae bloom. NMCL also
    highly
    recommends that whenever possible, the cleanest source water
    available should
    always be utilized.
    
Wednesday, August 6, 2014
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

2 comments:
I made a cal to Berkey over the weekend when this was on going and this is what I was told:
I went straight to Berkey and this is what they told me:
Nicole 15:49
At this time, we haven’t have data for Microcystin. It is a toxin produced by the bacteria. So even though the Black Berkey Elements can remove 99.9999% of bacteria, we cannot be certain it will remove this toxin. Therefore, we cannot recommend using the Berkey Elements to filter water contaminated with Microcystin.
I got a hold of Berkey on Saturday while this was on going and this is what I was told:
I went straight to Berkey and this is what they told me:
This is some very serious S#!%. I just talk to a Berkey Water filter Rep and this is what she told me:
Nicole 15:49
At this time, we haven’t have data for Microcystin. It is a toxin produced by the bacteria. So even though the Black Berkey Elements can remove 99.9999% of bacteria, we cannot be certain it will remove this toxin. Therefore, we cannot recommend using the Berkey Elements to filter water contaminated with Microcystin.
Post a Comment