"it's well shown that because the states have more guns, there's a lower crime rate" WHAT!? majority of criminals=everyday civilians=firearms more readily available and hence used
It is not quite as simple as your equality suggests. I don't think he was arguing that a well-armed state means a lower crime rate, as much as a state that has lots of private ownership has lower crime rates.
I'm not sure what you mean by "majority of criminals=everyday civilians". Do you mean as opposed to employees of the state, or military? Because the equality doesn't work if you reduce it; most civilians are not criminals.
While the connection between gun ownership and crime is complex, there does seem to be one relationship of note. Violent crime is less in places where victims are more likely to be armed. Criminals will take greater care that places are unoccupied before burglarizing, etc., to avoid confrontation.
It might not actually reduce crime, but I'd argue that a substitution of non-violent crime for violent crime is a positive.
Let's resolve this debate about guns versus crime with the only statistically valid study done to date. Even the statisticians who don't like the results of the study admit that the data and methods used in the study cannot be refuted, and therefore, neither can the results. Just check wikipedia for "Gary Kleck" to find out who he is. Then, very importantly, read this quote by someone who has always disagreed with Kleck's conclusions. It is a review of Kleck's work by one of his peers: http://www.pulpless.com/gunclock/peer.html
Now you know the objective facts. It's up to you to decide if you will live in accordance with those facts, or with your personal feelings.
Having been an LEO, I can tell you that Mir has obviously thought out his views and is frankly basing them greatly on reality. As a police officer we almost are never available to catch a criminal in the act or commission of a crime. What criminal is going to be stupid enough to commit a crime with the police around. Therefore if behooves the average person to have the ability to defend themselves.
Anonymous said... "it's well shown that because the states have more guns, there's a lower crime rate" WHAT!? majority of criminals=everyday civilians=firearms more readily available and hence used.
There is a glaring hole in your logic. Look at all the cities in America with high crime rates (NYC, LA, Chicago, Detroit, DC). They all have very high rates of violent crime. These are the also interestingly enough the places with the strictest gun control. No handguns are allowed in DC, NYC, or the president's hometown, yet they have ridicolous crime rates. In the Florida, the first state to liberalize conceal carry laws, their crime rate dropped approx. 15% the first year they allowed concealed carry.
Do the math. Human beings are the only animals stupid enough to feel bad about defending their own lives.
He's a proponent of self defense training hand to hand and especially firearms for civilians. So thats what he means about people carrying guns. I'm sure he envisions a future where they teach kids especially girls on how to defend themselves using knives, tasers and firearms. If such teachings were given in school by the time they are eighteen they will not be sitting defenseless ducks.
Guys, unless specifically told not to, I'll post the reply here in the blog so everyone can read it. I'll just leave the first name, and remove the last name, email or any other specific information for privacy reasons. Thanks
Leatherman Charge Ti
Fenix Lights
I love this light. Runs on a single AAA and is capable of big boy lumen output (80 lumens) in a keychain package. Also has low and mid mode for longer runtime.
Fenix PD20
Single CR123 cell. 6 modes including 180 lumen turbo mode.
General Mode: 9 lumens (35hrs) -> 47 lumens (6.5hrs) -> 94 lumens (2.6hrs) -> SOS
Turbo Mode: 180 lumens (1hrs) -> Strobe
15 days of survival use (2 continuous hours per day on the lowest setting)
Thanks for the Positive Reviews!
Energency gadget... on steroids.
Asus Eee 1005HA
Basic Door/Window Alarm
Emergency gadget
Both tool and weapon, just the right size
Straight edge makes it easier to sharpen, + tougher tip
Gorilla Tape
By all accounts and reviews I’ve read so far, it truly is “The toughest Tape on the Planet”
Transportation
I talked about these some time ago in an article, remember someone asked where to get one.
"Alternative Transportation"
Just found one reasonably priced and with excellent reviews in Amazon.
Best Folder
Emergency blankets. I Have several of these around.
Katadyn water filter
for the kits
and food ...
Got to have water: Klean Kanteen Stainless Steel
Moleskine, the ultimate little black cover notebook :)
Fenix L0D-CE. Perfect keychain light. 80 Lumens in a single AAA
Nice combo. The Soldier is an excellent product.
Sabre Red OC spray
Made in USA
This is the brand I use and always have one in my bag and car. ( same brand used by NYPD)
My wife keeps one in her purse too.
Sabre Red Tear Gas
Sabre Red for ladies
You guys have the coolest stuff up there.:)
Jack Bauer’s bag.:) I’d like to get one of these and try it out.
Fox OC Spray
Don’t have this one but it’s the hottest OC spray out there.
Someone once called it “bottled lava”
Pick your poison people, but do carry OC
1) Even if you carry a gun
2) SPECIALLY if you don’t carry a gun
Firesteel
Classic, and one of the few things I’d call a “must have” I own two of these.
My EDC bag: M1936 Musette Bag
Victorinox I bought recently. Most excellent tool, review coming up soon.
Make that "potable" water
And a more pricey alternative by Tikka
Just added one of these to my EDC bag, mostly for smoke, dust and debris
7 comments:
Frank Mir is a BAMF
Yeah I have seen this video and when I did it made me an even bigger frank mir fan.
Unfortunately, I have heard him say some things since that support socialism, which is disappointing.
"it's well shown that because the states have more guns, there's a lower crime rate"
WHAT!?
majority of criminals=everyday civilians=firearms more readily available and hence used
@Anonymous:
It is not quite as simple as your equality suggests. I don't think he was arguing that a well-armed state means a lower crime rate, as much as a state that has lots of private ownership has lower crime rates.
I'm not sure what you mean by "majority of criminals=everyday civilians". Do you mean as opposed to employees of the state, or military? Because the equality doesn't work if you reduce it; most civilians are not criminals.
While the connection between gun ownership and crime is complex, there does seem to be one relationship of note. Violent crime is less in places where victims are more likely to be armed. Criminals will take greater care that places are unoccupied before burglarizing, etc., to avoid confrontation.
It might not actually reduce crime, but I'd argue that a substitution of non-violent crime for violent crime is a positive.
Let's resolve this debate about guns versus crime with the only statistically valid study done to date. Even the statisticians who don't like the results of the study admit that the data and methods used in the study cannot be refuted, and therefore, neither can the results. Just check wikipedia for "Gary Kleck" to find out who he is. Then, very importantly, read this quote by someone who has always disagreed with Kleck's conclusions. It is a review of Kleck's work by one of his peers: http://www.pulpless.com/gunclock/peer.html
Now you know the objective facts. It's up to you to decide if you will live in accordance with those facts, or with your personal feelings.
Having been an LEO, I can tell you that Mir has obviously thought out his views and is frankly basing them greatly on reality. As a police officer we almost are never available to catch a criminal in the act or commission of a crime. What criminal is going to be stupid enough to commit a crime with the police around. Therefore if behooves the average person to have the ability to defend themselves.
Anonymous said...
"it's well shown that because the states have more guns, there's a lower crime rate"
WHAT!?
majority of criminals=everyday civilians=firearms more readily available and hence used.
There is a glaring hole in your logic. Look at all the cities in America with high crime rates (NYC, LA, Chicago, Detroit, DC). They all have very high rates of violent crime. These are the also interestingly enough the places with the strictest gun control. No handguns are allowed in DC, NYC, or the president's hometown, yet they have ridicolous crime rates. In the Florida, the first state to liberalize conceal carry laws, their crime rate dropped approx. 15% the first year they allowed concealed carry.
Do the math. Human beings are the only animals stupid enough to feel bad about defending their own lives.
He's a proponent of self defense training hand to hand and especially firearms for civilians. So thats what he means about people carrying guns. I'm sure he envisions a future where they teach kids especially girls on how to defend themselves using knives, tasers and firearms. If such teachings were given in school by the time they are eighteen they will not be sitting defenseless ducks.
Post a Comment